Shakespeare v.s. Moss

I really wanted to compare Shall I Compare Thee To A Summers Day. This poem was written by two different writers yet when you read Shakespeare's you get a sense of hapiness. A sense of love and brightness overcomes me but when i read Moss's i feel they are nothing alike. Moss writes so much more literal and it doesn't seem as though they are the same poem. Shakespeare's is happy until Moss writes the literal meaning of it (more modern reading of it shall I say) and it just seems sad.